Real-world reviews
Wirecutter is compatible with readers. When you purchase links on our site, we may earn a partner fee. Learn even more
If you don’t need to give your child a smartphone, but you need them to have a way of talking as they become more independent, a smartwatch or a top phone may be your answer. After trying 8 of those devices with our own two-year-olds, a smartwatch is a bigger choice than a shell telephone for maximum families. Unlike a shell phone, a smartwatch will allow you to track your child’s position and manage who talks to him. In addition, kids will intuitively know how to use their touchscreen. We like the Verizon GizmoWatch 2 better.
Verizon’s GizmoWatch 2 allows your child to make and get voice calls with up to 10 designated numbers. With an app on your own smartphone, you can also track your child’s location and send them a text message. The child can respond with emojis, predefined texts like “I need to move home” or a voice message. And since the GizmoWatch 2 is sold in Verizon stores, you can faint with a watch, as well as gain visitor benefits if needed, which is not the case with our finalist, the TickTalk 3.
Advertising
The TickTalk 3 does everything the GizmoWatch 2 does and allows a child to call more people and make video calls. But we found that the screen responds less.
Like the Verizon GizmoWatch 2, the TickTalk 3 is a child-specific smartwatch that pairs with an app on the parent’s smartphone so the adult can call, text and track a child’s whereabouts. Children can answer with a phone or video call, send one of the many predefined text messages, or use a keyboard on the watch to call anyone; parents can turn off this feature. But the TickTalk 3 is only available online and is not sold at point of sale or through a wireless service provider, which means you must set it up and connect it yourself to a cellular network.
Similar to a small wireless speaker, the relay serves as an ultra-reliable walkie-talkie that also tracks your child’s whereabouts. It is available in various colors.
At the time of publication, the value of $40.
The Pocket Relay device works on Relay’s patented 4G LTE network, allowing you to incorporate GPS tracking and alert you if your child is moving away from a designated location. Only other people with some other related relay or app (available through iTunes and Google Play and related to your device account) can tap them. To use the Relay device, a child holds down a button to chat on their own designated line, walkie-talkie style. A small button on the look takes the device from one frequency to another and also scrolls through a music channel, a translation channel and a prank channel.
This smart watch makes voice calls and text messages, and you can track your child’s location.
The TickTalk 3 does everything the GizmoWatch 2 does and allows a child to call more people and make video calls. But we found that the screen responds less.
Similar to a small wireless speaker, the relay serves as an ultra-reliable walkie-talkie that also tracks your child’s whereabouts. It is available in various colors.
At the time of publication, the value of $40.
This consultant is particularly for parents who need a compromised device to talk to a child but still don’t want to equip their child with a smartphone. (We have lines of consultants to reuse an old smartphone or pill for your child, as well as a consultant for parental controls to block or limit usage.) While some parents may be discouraged by the expense of a smartphone, many others are basically involved about the addictive qualities of phones and are an easier and less charged communication tool.
In fact, the fear that smartphones, and screen use in general, may affect sleep, intellectual fitness and bullying, has led many parents to dedicate themselves to “waiting for 8” and not buying a smartphone for their children until the child is in eighth grade. Meanwhile, the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic and the upcoming cancellation of many face-to-face classes, camps, and extracurricular activities would likely lead some parents to consider giving their child a pre-planned device. People who need to inspire their children to play alone outdoors but are involved with the exact place their children are or what might go wrong, can use a smartwatch or a covered phone to stay in touch with their children if needed.
Our pre-pandemic surveys and non-public reports have led us to conclude that many others prefer a less hooked and distracting option for young people between the ages of 8 and 13, a time when most young people venture alone in the world. at a time when you will no longer find a pay phone in the convenience store or in the school hallway. A 2019 survey through Common Sense Media found that 53% of young people have their own smartphone at 11 and 69% have one at 12. Meanwhile, the number of 8-year-olds with smartphones has increased from 11% in 2015 to 19%. 2019.
Giving young people their own phone can make it significantly easier to communicate and coordinate the family circle. But this is still a complicated selection for many parents. Tweens and teens spend more and more time in front of the screen: more than seven hours a day for teens and nearly five hours for tweens, according to the same (prepandemic) test through Common Sense Media. Having a smartphone means that a screen is even more available and tempting. It is understandable that many parents have to wait, and there are even imperfect alternatives.
To study this guide, I spoke to more than a dozen parents in the user and interviewed another dozen through their children’s social media, cell phones and smartwatches. I also called a handful of friends of my 10- and 11-year-old daughter to get her opinion. I interviewed a generation analyst to get a market concept as well as representatives from various device manufacturers. To see what can be obtained for the physical shopper, I visited at-T, Verizon, Best Buy and Target retail outlets in my neighborhood. I also read online reviews, blog posts and reports on smartwatches for young people and basic phones.
As a previous-generation journalist, I reported on cell generation trends for the San Francisco Chronicle and CNBC.com. I’m also Wirecutter’s consultant on the most productive apps to manage a child’s smartphone and tips on how to set up a pill for kids. Finally, as the father of a woman in college, I have a direct, non-public interest in locating and opting for a device that doesn’t distract her with endless games and apps, but that allows me to monitor her when she starts venturing. Only.
Smartwatches and cap phones, also known as multifunction phones, basic phones or stupid phones, all offer pros and cons. The one that makes sense for your family circle is based on the connection your child wants and whether he needs more features like GPS tracking and parental control.
Smartwatches are technologically more complex than mobile phones; they can track your child’s location by GPS, and you can remotely monitor or restrict your child’s calls, which you can’t do with a basic phone.
Children’s smartwatches have taken off, especially in China, where 23.9 million smartwatches were sold in 2019, according to generation market research company IDC. Children’s smartwatches are not yet a hit in the U.S., where around 95,000 were sold in 2019, said Ramon Llamas, IDC’s director of mobile device studies. But Llamas expects the numbers to rise this year now that more and more U.S. cell phone operators are starting to sell them (smartwatches for young people want to be connected to a cellular network; they don’t connect to Wi-Fi).
Smart watches for kids usually charge about $200, plus a monthly service fee, some have recently lowered charges to less than $100. They work on the 4G LTE network. Until recently, Verizon Wireless was the only wireless service provider in the U.S. Selling a smartwatch for young people (our choice, the GizmoWatch 2); Since then, T-Mobile has brought FamilyConnect Timex, which we plan to test, and Sprint has announced WatchMeGo, which is recently sold out. Some young-fashioned smartwatches, such as the Coolpad Dyno, will offer their own cellular network plan, while TickTalk 3, our choice of moment, can run on a timeline added to your existing AT-T or T-Mobile plan (TickTalk recommends using your partner, Red Pocket Mobile, because it’s cheaper).
Equipped with a SIM card and a phone number, such as a cell phone, the watches we test can make voice calls, some can even make grainy video calls as well as receive text messages. Parents can dial the watch number and attach it to their child’s smartwatch via an iPhone or Android app. The app allows parents to control the clock and add who can touch their child. Parents can also track their children’s position on a map in the app, and in some cases, they can set up an alert that lights up if the child leaves a specific location. I discovered that location tracking is useful and reassuring because it gave my child the freedom to move alone into a friend’s space or football practice and allowed me to check where I was without having to call or send them a message. However, experts raise considerations about over-monitoring, especially for tweens and adolescents who expand independence.
Children instinctively know how to use a smartwatch, dragging it to navigate the touchscreen. But those watches can be giant and bulky for a small doll, so make sure your child is in a position to wear them. In addition, some teachers and schools have begun banning smartwatches in the classroom, as well as cell phones, as devices can be a distraction.
Connected watches are not designed for long conversations. You’re on speaker, so there’s no privacy. They also do not intend to allow young people to stay in touch with friends, as they allow a child to text only other people with a connected smartphone app, which are usually their parents (it is also a fact that the child can ‘t participate in the organization’s texts). Smartwatches should also be recharged regularly. Our circle of relatives had many cases where we realized, at the time my son needed to get out, that the battery of the smartwatch was low.
Another fear about smartwatches is the risk of piracy, espionage and personal knowledge gathering about young people. A 2017 report (PDF) from the Norwegian Consumer Council has issued warnings about protection flaws in some young-fashioned smartwatches, although the smartwatches in the report are not the same brands or models we tested for this guide. U.S. customer teams have asked the Federal Trade Commission (PDF) to investigate these fears, and in 2018, the FTC warned brands of two smartwatches to gather knowledge without authorization. (We chose not to consider either for this guide). It’s a smart concept to use a strong and unique password when setting up your account (a password manager can help you) and run firmware or app updates when you’re invited to. We talk about the device express privacy policies we present in What about privacy issues? Down.
Finally, the watch brands for young sages with which we spoke stated that their target audience is five- to ten-year-olds, which is reflected in the most childish graphics, art and design of watches. Tweens and teens over the age of 11 are expected to ask them to use a smartphone. Although the initial youth phone market hit a wall (see the disappearance of devices like the Firefly), we think many parents would like to see a smartwatch or a smartphone combination designed with tweens and teens in mind.
Although the corporations that make those fundamental phones call them “multifunctional phones”, their quality determination, through existing standards, is a lack of capacity (the call goes back to when phones can do anything more than make calls feel rich in functions). They are a return to the days before iPhones (2007) and Android phones (2008), and have not been very up-to-date since.
There are some apparent drawbacks to buying a multifunction phone for your child: first, there’s no smartphone app that matches a critical phone, so you have much less visibility into how your child uses the phone. You can’t use those fundamental phones to track your child’s position. And we won our first spam call a few hours after setting up our first fundamental phone.
Multi-purpose phones work mainly on the old 3G wireless network, although Alcatel Smartflip and Alcatel Go Flip 3 work on the 4G network. (Avoid multifunction phones running on a 2G network; cellular operators are eliminating 2G). Although basic phones can connect to the Internet, their browsing is clumsy and the connection is slow, which deserves to discourage unthinking Internet browsing and social media without interruption. media: a disproportionate benefit for parents.
If your kids have grown up like mine, not knowing anything yet on a touchscreen, they will probably need to be informed about how to send text messages (i.e., keep the keyboard buttons numbered to choose each letter), make a phone call and navigate the commands on a critical phone. You should expect nothing more than a superficial text message from your child, even if you can send him a long message from his smartphone.
Unlike smartphones, you can only send one-on-one text messages with a basic phone. A text with more than one user looks like a multimedia message that you want to be downloaded, which makes it maximum to participate in an organization discussion. It took us several minutes to download an undeniable check organization text message, too long for anyone who is used to the almost instantaneous speed of trendy texting. This can be embarrassing if your child shares the car, for example, or in any scenario where the rest of the organization coordinates the main points collectively. (Again, this also prevents constant pings from young people who still don’t say “Hello” to the organization.) One parent said he eventually relented in and bought his daughter a smartphone to be included in the text messages of his ride-sharing organization. If most of your child’s peers already own a smartphone, using a multifunction phone will cause your child to be excluded from text messages from your organization.
Another disadvantage is that if you want help with your basic phone, you may not easily find someone to help you; On one of my trips to the AT-T store, a representative looked at my phone without saying anything and told me he couldn’t help me because AT-T wasn’t dressed up with him. These phones are also constantly updated or deleted.
On the plus side, the battery life of a critical telephone is much longer than that of a smartphone or smartwatch. In standby mode with minimal use, the fundamental telephones we tested lasted several days with a bachelor’s position. These phone phones also tend to be more durable than smartwatches for kids. And the maximum fundamental telephones are quite reasonable compared to a smartphone or smartwatch: you can seamlessly buy a basic phone phone for less than $100 or even less than $50.
Based on our conversations with parents and children, we test the following features and functions when searching for smartwatches and “stupid” phones:
Communication: Parents and young people deserve to be able to seamlessly transmit fundamental data in real time, such as where a child deserves to be collected. The ultimate way of effectiveness is to make a voice call regularly, texting and video calls are also effective.
Messages: For cases where a child or parent is unavailable, the other party will need to be able to leave a message that can be recovered later.
Distractions: We look for minimal distractions on the device, which means limiting yourself to the Internet and social networks and preferably few or no games.
Sustainability: Although we did not expect the device to be unbreakable, it can be thrown, hit and dropped to the ground.
Position tracking: We enjoy the peace of mind of the brain and the convenience of following a child’s position, but we don’t meet this requirement because we recognize that not everyone is looking for such a feature.
Children’s Attraction: We’ve taken into account features that can appeal to young and tweens, such as opting for colors, ringtones or other tactics to customize the device.
I checked 8 devices with my 12- and 10-year-old daughters. To verify cover phones, I trusted an AT-T prepaid SIM card with SMS, voice calls, and data, you can seamlessly restrict your phone’s features by purchasing a voice-only plan. For smartwatches and Relay, I downloaded the corresponding apps to my iPhone X (which works on the AT-T network).
I spent more than 3 months phones and watches, sending them with my kids to school, football and softball training, and anywhere they went alone. To check the effectiveness of the devices in communication, my 12-year-old son took them to a playground 1 km away, called me and read random passages from a book. I also dropped the appliances on a hardwood floor from a table about 2 feet from the ground. My daughter’s friends, ages 10 to 12, also played with them and presented their comments.
This smart watch makes voice calls and text messages, and you can track your child’s location.
Oconsisist with or: Verizon (although you don’t want to be a Verizon mobile phone visitor to get a plan) Network: 4G LTEPotentiel Distraction: Fun Noise App, Location Support Fitness Game: Yes Monthly Service Taxes: From $5 consistent with the month for Verizon consumers or $10 per month for non-Verizon consumers
The Verizon GizmoWatch 2, a recent update to the GizmoWatch (pictured above) is a baby smartwatch that allows your child to call up to 10 designated people, as well as send and receive text messages with you via a smartphone app. It also allows you to track your child’s position. The GizmoWatch 2 doesn’t allow personal conversations (all calls are made more commonly on the speaker), however, it gives you more parenting equipment than a basic phone, which is useful if you need to keep an eye on your children’s goings and goings and using technology. .
With an elongated profile, Verizon GizmoWatch 2 looks almost like an Apple Watch and has many of the same fundamental features, such as a touchscreen and a variety of watch faces (or watch wallpapers). Navigating GizmoWatch 2 is more intuitive for kids than using a multifunctional phone; they simply slide left, right, more sensitive and down, and tap on the touch screen or one of the two buttons on the right side of the watch. Kids can customize the watch by opting for one of the seven wallpapers, such as the fundamental black or “under the sea”, and one of the 8 ringtones (also vibrates). A speaker on your watch allows your child to communicate with you or record a voice message for you. When we used it, our calls were brief but clear.
We discovered that gizmoWatch’s corresponding smartphone app was the most intuitive kids smartwatch app we’ve tested, all working the same way in general. To connect, parents can make a phone call by accessing the smartphone app or dialing the watch number directly. During this time, the child can call up to 10 designated contacts on GizmoWatch 2. If someone calls the watch and is not a designated phone number, the call is interrupted and does not connect.
With the app, parents can also send emojis and text messages up to 120 characters. The child can respond with emojis, a voice recording or one of the 20 predefined messages like “When do you take me?” or “I don’t feel good.” (Parents can edit and customize predefined clock text messages in the parent app). Please note that you can only send SMS through the Gizmo app (available for iOS and Android; designated contacts will need to associate the app with the watch). so that young people can’t text their friends and can’t participate in the organization’s text messages.
Compared to a smartphone, the GizmoWatch 2 has features that take at least time, even though it includes some fun and potentially distracting activities that we haven’t noticed on the other smartwatches tested. For example, you can make a short voice recording and then erase it to sound as if it had absorbed helium or grew like a monster. There is also a game that encourages young people to jump and be active.
As with other smartwatches for kids, parents can track the location of the GizmoWatch 2 in the Gizmo smartphone app. Although the feature requires a giant battery, it can take time to qualify and may not work, you can even see the location of the watch in real time, which was not available on the other watches we tested. In one case, my daughter took a long time to walk home after softball training. By turning on the tracker in real time, I can see that it had stopped in the game box and was running everywhere (apparently looped). You can also set up an alert to alert you if your child has left a specific location, such as school.
The watch is enclosed in a waterproof plastic case and comes with a rubber strap that can be upgraded with any popular 20mm bracelet. During our tests, he endured multiple falls and bumps. The GizmoWatch has also been named the most productive smartwatch to track your child through Safewise, a site that reviews protection features. Because it is sold through Verizon, the GizmoWatch 2 requires little effort to be configured (the TickTalk 3, our choice of moment, requires you to turn it on yourself or even buy your own SIM card). It also means it’s easier to have visitors than with other smartwatches.
Many parents have given the original GizmoWatch less than stellar reviews due to its duration and wobbly user experience, and we disagree. The GizmoWatch is bulky, with a wider profile than the TickTalk (or even an Apple Watch), and only comes with a plastic wristband (although you can change it). Not all young people will find it comfortable or won’t need to use it. My own children would take it off and keep it in their wallet or backpacks.
My children were also told not to wear it in class, as teachers discovered that these watches were a distraction and that devices can simply (or may not) make sounds at times out of the time; one of the applications, for example, is just to make silly noises, like fart sounds. Parents also complained that their children had “numbered” them because the touchscreen may be too sensitive.
Bright colors, graphics and wallpapers (superhero, “under the sea”) also give the GizmoWatch a younger feel, perhaps too much. As for battery life, the fully charged watch can last more than a day, however, there have been many occasions when we sought to use it only to notice that it was running out of battery.
Ten designated contacts may not be enough for your family. Tracking the position in the app can be slow and is not updated automatically. there’s probably a delay in seeing where your child is in real time. The GizmoWatch 2 costs $100 on a two-year contract, and as one of the parents we know discovered, unfortunately, this makes it an expensive device to lose for your child.
The TickTalk 3 does everything the GizmoWatch 2 does and allows a child to call more people and make video calls. But we found that the screen responds less.
Provider: Network Pocket Mobile (partner), AT-T, T-Mobile Network: 4G LTE Potential distraction: built-in camera allows video chats and location tracking: yes Monthly service: from $10 consistent with the red pocket mobile month
If you’re looking for an option for the GizmoWatch 2 that runs on AT-T or an AT-T-compatible network, with just a few bells and whistles and a design that would possibly be more enjoyable to navigate for an older child, the TickTalk 3 under radar Just like the elongated GizmoWatch 2, the TickTalk 3 square has only two buttons and a touch screen. The silver button on the look turns on the watch and can program the red button to make an emergency call, a feature that the GizmoWatch 2 does not have. TickTalk 3 also includes location tracking. One of the biggest drawbacks, however, is that the touchscreen might not respond frustratingly; It took a lot of clicks, for example, for us to get off the screen of a photo gallery.
The other disadvantage is the clock setting: unlike the Verizon GizmoWatch 2, which you can buy from a Verizon store, you’re only when you set up TickTalk 3. A Red Pocket Mobile SIM card comes with the TickTalk 3; you want to turn on the card and insert it yourself into the watch. (TickTalk’s partnership with Red Pocket Mobile means you can request a pay-as-you-go plan starting at $10 according to the month, which is less expensive than connecting through other wireless service providers). You also have the option to choose some other compatible ones. Wireless compatible with or yet even then, you will be waiting to set up the watch yourself, as it is not sold or supported via AT-T, T-Mobile or any other U.S. cellular service compatible with or.
Like the GizmoWatch 2, parents can use the TickTalk 3 to connect directly with their child by making a phone call through the smartphone app or dialing the clock number. Parents can also ask the watch to call them, which the GizmoWatch does not (although you can make sure GizmoWatch automatically answers a call after a while). Parents can designate up to 50 more people (compared to 10 with the GizmoWatch) who can touch the child and can prevent anyone from calling the watch. The TickTalk 3 is the only watch we’ve tested with a virtual keyboard that allows kids to make calls to anyone from the watch, a feature that parents can block or activate. Although our control calls were clear, a parent whose son we know has a TickTalk 3 complained that the audio had parasites.
The TickTalk 3, like the GizmoWatch 2, also allows parents to send emojis, texts and voice messages to their kids through the smartphone app. The child can respond with emojis, a voice recording that lasts up to a minute or a predefined text like “I almost get there”. As with GizmoWatch, young people can only send text messages to the related smartphone app. As a result, they can’t send text messages with their friends or participate in text messages from your organization.
Unlike the GizmoWatch 2, TickTalk 3 has no games or activities. Parents can also set the clock to “do not disturb” at certain times of the day. But this has the possibility to be distracted by the additional capacity of an integrated camera, which young people can use to chat by video, as well as to take pictures and record short videos.
As with the other smartwatches we tested, parents can track the location of the TickTalk 3 via the corresponding smartphone app. In theory, they can also hint at the clock’s location history during an era, this function did not work when we tried. Unlike GizmoWatch, in this model, you can’t set up an alert to tell you if your child is wandering beyond the designated geographic boundaries. And while parent experts advise opposing monitoring, TickTalk 3 also includes a “super audition” mode in which you should pay attention to your child, a feature that did not offer any other screens that we tested. However, when I tried, I struggled to understand what my daughter and her friends were saying. Therefore, we don’t think it’s the most effective spying tool anyway.
This watch is enclosed in a black or white plastic case and comes with a nylon strap woven into one selection of colors, which you can remove and change for another. We found that the overall design of the TickTalk 3 more excited tweens who didn’t need a smartwatch for young people who looked like “babies.”
Similar to a small wireless speaker, the relay serves as an ultra-reliable walkie-talkie that also tracks your child’s whereabouts. It is available in various colors.
At the time of publication, the value of $40.
Oconsistente with or: Republic Wireless Network: 4G LTE Potential Distraction: A Joke and Suivi Music Channels Location: Yes Monthly Service: $10 Consistent with Month via Republic Wireless (Relay Parent Company)
Relay is neither a phone nor a watch, but a compact, screenless device that allows your child to stay in touch with you, as well as as a parent of a smartphone or smartwatch. A relatively inexpensive, sturdy, water-resistant and gummy-resistant 3 to 3 inch square looks like a small wireless speaker. It has only 3 yettons: a small-strength yetton and a volume yetton on the side, and a giant major yetton that your child can press to communicate. You can purchase a bracelet, a buckle case with a musket or a thong for easy transport.
Like children’s smartwatches, the relay runs on a 4G LTE network, but works like a walkie-talkie. Press and hold the main button to talk; only one user can speak at a time. Communicating through a walkie-talkie can be fun but difficult. During our test, my 10-year-old daughter needed at least 3 attempts to connect me and hear her read a sentence from a book. In addition, leaving and retrieving messages is clumsy; Since the device has only 3 buttons, navigation can be confusing at first.
Unlike a fundamental telephone or smart watch, there is no telephone number to dial on the relay. The device connects to an app on a smartphone and other relay devices only; create channels to chat one by one or in a larger group. The closed network provides security, but limits your child’s ability to touch those who don’t have a connected relay or app.
As with smartwatches, you can track your child’s position on a map in the Relay smartphone app. You can also load other channels, adding a daily prank chain and a translation string (using Google Translate). A favorite of one of my daughter’s 11-year-old friends, the music channel, turned Relay into a mini speaker (you can move and buy music on Relay via its USB charging cable; you can also connect a headset pay attention to music). The strings can be fun and distract a little, but since there is no screen, the relay avoids the traps of a smartphone to the maximum.
We found that it was almost unlikely to decide which folding phone was most productive for young people. Options vary by wireless service provider and availability of specific style settings on a regular basis. In general, the concentration of the market in smartphones means that there is not much availability or visitor support for basic phones; Stores and wireless service providers offer dozens of smartphone options, usually only offering one or two basic phones. Our studies and tests have led us to conclude that smartwatches for young people will offer more features to help parents manage communication with their children.
That said, a shell phone can be a springboard to a smartphone, tends to be less expensive than a smartwatch, poses minimal distractions and allows young people to communicate or text with their friends (albeit awkwardly) without any problem. restrict how many other people can be included in this communication network. We have some favorite features based on several weeks of testing. If you don’t place those phones especially at retail points or prefer a different look, use the criteria in the How We Select and Test segment to decide the most productive option for your favorite carrier.
A clamshell-like black basic phone, the reasonable Alcatel Smartflip, also sold as Alcatel Go Flip 3, is widely used in physical outlets such as Best Buy and Target and with operators such as AT-T, Cricket Wireless and T-Mobile. (The Alcatel Smartflip is related to AT-T and Cricket Wireless, while the Alcatel Go Flip 3 is connected to T-Mobile and Metro via T-Mobile; they are necessarily the same thing). We haven’t tried Verizon’s Alcatel Go Flip V, which is similar but doesn’t come with the same preloaded apps. Clamshell teletephones are primarily intended to make phone calls and get SMS messages, something the Alcatel Smartflip does well. Our phone calls were transparent and the text messages were undeniable to read on the 2.8-inch screen. Although it doesn’t have a touchscreen, this shell teletelet is undeniable to use, with large buttons and undeniable navigation.
However, please note that, like most other shell phones, this phone does not have a QWERTY keyboard. Your child wants to be informed about how to use a T9 keyboard to write a message by holding down a number to choose the right letter: old school. In addition, your child can’t participate in organization discussions via SMS, which arrive as multimedia messages and require a lot of time to download. The Alcatel Smartflip and Go Flip 3 are preloaded with Google Assistant, which means your child has access to YouTube, which can be incredibly distracted and can’t be removed.
Relaunched in 2017, the Nokia 3310 is another of our favorite clamshell teletephone options. It is a “redesigned” update of the once popular phone and has won many accolades for its modern and old-fashioned look. It comes in 4 colors, adding a bright yellow or orange, which would possibly be more attractive to tweens and teens than the fundamental black of the Alcatel. Like Alcatel’s clamshell teleteletéphone, the Nokia 3310 is primarily aimed at phone calls and text messages. It makes phone calls reliably and can read text messages seamlessly on the 2.4-inch color display. But just like Alcatel’s clamshell teletephone, the Nokia 3310 only has one virtual keyboard, so your child wants to be informed about how to use a T9 keyboard to write a message, keeping a number to choose the right letter. They cannot be painted for organizational texts.
We also found that it was annoying that the Nokia 3310 was constantly locked while we were there, forcing us to prevent it and push to unlock it over and over again, which had nothing to do with the Alcatel. It comes with some pretty innocent distractions: a preloaded Snake game and Facebook and Twitter apps, which are so clumsy to navigate that they deserve to discourage overuse. The unlocked Nokia 3310 is only available for AT-T and AT-T-enabled wireless carriers; it’s not for Verizon or Sprint.
Constant monitoring of young people and tweens is a thorny topic, as some experts in children’s progression think that monitoring young people can also disrupt the agreement between parents and children and save them the progression of independence. Privacy advocates are also involved in the more constantly everyone is exposed to surveillance, the more they will get used to it. Monitoring your children would possibly seem trivial, but it would possibly also be a way to have a vision of and settle for global privacy, which can also have a lasting effect on their concepts on anonymity and autonomy. If you make the decision to turn on position tracking, don’t do it in secret. Instead, contact your child and let him know that he will be watching his whereabouts.
With respect to the knowledge collected through these devices, young people gain advantages from express online privacy coverage under the Children’s Online Privacy Act (COPPA), which limits the type of knowledge a company may collect about a child under the age of 13. uses knowledge and for how long a company helps maintain knowledge. But device brands can bypass this type of coverage by assuming the customer is the parent, not the child. By doing so, they can collect and use all the knowledge they need from their parents’ account, just as they would any other application.
Because of the amount of sensitive knowledge these devices accumulate about you and your child, adding location and voice recordings, it’s vital to perceive how corporations can use the knowledge they collect.
Calling Gizmo’s privacy policy confusing is falling short. It is very brief, however, to perceive it, you also want to read Verizon’s privacy policy; as stated in Gizmo’s policy, “Gizmo’s privacy practices are covered through Verizon’s privacy policy as well as through the practices described here.” Verizon, in accordance with its policy, would possibly retain the data “provided it is mandatory for commercial, accounting, tax or legal purposes”, but Verizon has told us that it retains Gizmo’s knowledge for only 60 days. Verizon assumes that the parent accepts the policy and the company collects the knowledge accordingly. In addition to the knowledge you provide, such as your name, phone number, location, and email address, Verizon collects the main points of the device and would possibly use the knowledge for analysis. Verizon does not use the knowledge collected from GizmoWatch for marketing purposes, however, it is unclear whether Verizon may use the knowledge collected in another meaningful person’s smartphone app or on the online page for interest-based ads.
Like Verizon, TickTalk considers the parent to be the visitor in its privacy policy and the company does not provide a separate policy for children. TickTalk collects data about the physical location of the device and app on your phone, as well as non-identifiable data about your phone or network address. The company may retain the data “as long as we consider that there is a need or gain advantages for the company”. TickTalk can use a percentage of knowledge with analytics companies, for marketing (although this requires you to communicate) and with a variety of popular industry third parties, such as technical support, fraud investigations, and law enforcement. This policy is Verizon’s privacy policy for GizmoWatch.
Relay provides privacy policies for parents and children, something neither Verizon nor TickTalk does. We are inspired by the clarity of children’s privacy policy, which limits knowledge collection and obviously describes the company’s use of data. In particular, Relay maintains only the latest location, you can configure someone else’s smartphone app to record a longer history. Relay is also very explicit about the exchange of knowledge: “We do not use the content of any voice messages or location data for marketing purposes and we do not sell or have this data available to third parties for use for marketing purposes. “
Experts will offer 3 key tips to stick to once your child receives a cell phone (whether smart or “stupid”). Many of these tips can also be applied to using Wisewatch:
Designate schedules without cell phone or spaces without cell phone. Experts propose to ban the use of devices at certain times of the day, such as dinner and, if possible, keep mobile phones out of certain parts of the house, such as dormitories. More importantly, parents, as role models, also deserve to stick to this directive.
Make transparent regulations. Children between the ages of 8 and 12 can look forward to delighting their parents, according to Dr. Megan Moreno, a pediatrician and senior writer of the American Academy of Pediatrics policy on youth and media use. (We interviewed Moreno for our app consultant to manage a child’s smartphone). “We found that young children actually want to interact with parents about the regulations and what they are intended to do,” Moreno said. “They’re hungry to have this conversation.” Reduce cell phone time at night, when young people want to sleep. A 2018 test of 8- to 11-year-olds found that those who were physically active for at least 60 minutes a day slept nine to 11 hours at night and did not spend more than two hours a day on high-scoring recreational screens. in language, elaboration of plans and other tests of intellectual tasks that young people who did not meet any of the 3 criteria (although it is difficult to analyze the correlation or causation of the factors).
Set expectations. One of the court cases we heard from parents was that their child had forgotten his device, had not reloaded it, or had never answered calls or text messages on his phone or shell clock, which was contrary to the goal of having one. One way to answer: Encourage young people to use their smartphones or smartwatches as planned by presenting them as a way to prove they are in a position and guilty enough to have a smartphone, said Katherine Reynolds Lewis of The Good News About Bad Behavior and the Mom aged 14, 16, and 27. You can also describe your expectations in a contract between you and your child, describe the consequences if your child loses the device, and document regulations, such as when a child should have his or her phone with him, with whom he or she is allowed to communicate. what kind of data is never worth percentages (personal address, for example).
If you’re looking for more recommendations, The New York Times has published a consultant on how and when to restrict the use of generation by young people, from infants to teens. The American Academy of Pediatrics provides a tool to create a family circle media plan, adding a calculator that determines how long a child deserves to be allowed to spend time on the screen, comparing it to the amount of sleep and activity time they need. Common Sense Media answers questions about screen time, studies how young people use generation, and gives parents tips and recommendations on how to use generation healthily.
We plan to review some other young smartwatches in the coming months, and once we do, we will update this consultant with our ideas. Lately we’ve been testing T-Mobile’s Timex FamilyConnect, a new smartwatch for young people that, like our choices, makes calls, texts and allows parents to track their children’s position. Sprint WatchMeGo has been exhausted lately (Sprint and T-Mobile were officially merged on April 1, 2020, so the long term of this smartwatch is uncertain); Like other smartwatches for kids, it makes calls, texts and allows parents to track their children’s position.
Rumor has it that Fitbit is launching a smartwatch for young people. The company recently acquired Doki Technologies, manufacturer of the recently defunct dokiPal young smartwatch. Fitbit lately offers the Fitbit Ace 2, a youth activity tracker that doesn’t come with any communication tools. We’ll try a Fitbit smartwatch for young people whenever it’s available.
Offering what tech sites have called the stupidest smartphone for kids, Gabb Wireless brought the first generation of its telephone in September 2019 after a successful collective funding crusade and recently announced the Gabb Z2, which we will test. A ZTE smart teleteletlet that runs on a 4G network and is available for most of the United States (with the exception of Alaska), Gabb’s wireless telephone is stripped of Internet access, apps and games, allowing only phone calls, SMS, calendar and RADIO FM. Parents cannot track the location of the child’s teleteletphone, the company has announced plans to load this feature in the future.
We didn’t read about any smartwatch or cell phone based on a 2G network. We also do not consider the new iPod touch or young smartwatches made through Fitbit (for activity tracking and fitness), Garmin (for activity tracking and fitness), VTech (for taking photos and videos) or hereO (for tracking location) as they do not come with Array voice calls of voice messages or text messages. Similarly, we do not use child tracking devices like Jiobit or Tile, as they also do not have a means of communication. We also made the decision not to review the AngelSense, which is designed for young people with special needs.
The Coolpad Dyno was introduced in early 2019 and was highlighted at CES 2019. With a retail value of $60 plus the $10 per month wireless service rate that connects the smartwatch to the Coolpad network, this is the most affordable young-for-money smartwatch we’ve ever tested. Like GizmoWatch 2 and TickTalk 3, Coolpad Dyno connects to a smartphone app, allowing parents to call the clock and track the watch’s location. During our tests, however, the screen broke beyond any solution when my daughter took it with her to football training. We don’t know if we won a faulty watch or if the clock was crushed by a football or sharp football tip while it was in his bag. Coolpad sent us a momentary clock, which survived the launch, adding a wooden floor. But by the time the clock stopped, we were still involved in that parts like the small plastic layer of the cargo port could come off smoothly, and we found that GizmoWatch 2 and TickTalk 3 seemed to be of higher quality and exciting for tweens. while the Coolpad Dyno is obviously intended for children over 8 years of age or younger. On the one hand, you have the possibility to choose from seven wallpapers, but they are all cartoons and dinosaurs.
We tested the dokiPal smartwatch, but on July 1, 2020, the company announced that its devices were no longer available or operational. Launched in July 2019, the newest dokiPal smartwatch, a well-designed device that worked on a 4G LTE-compatible network. Like TickTalk 3, it included not only text messages and voice calls, but also video calls. However, we found that the dokiPal smartphone app is less intuitive than apps for GizmoWatch and TickTalk.
The Light Phone 2 began shipping a limited number of devices in the fall of 2019. Worth between $300 and $400, the Light Phone 2 is not for tweens and teens, but for adults looking to restrict screen usage. However, the Light Phone 2 has attracted attention as a minimalist phone, and the “Wait until 8th” crusade has indexed it as a possible choice for the smartphone. It works on a 4G LTE network like a smartphone, but only allows you to perform some tasks, such as making voice calls, sending text messages, setting an alarm, receiving instructions, and calling a carpool service. There is no camera, internet browser or app store. One feature the manufacturer is contemplating is an app that can monitor the location of the phone, which parents have requested, said Kaiwei Tang, co-founder of Light. However, the main goal of Light Phone 2 is to prevent adults and young people from seeing their smartphones all the time. “The smartphone is so sturdy that even if it’s off, it distracts you,” Tang said. We intend to check the Light Phone 2 once the tracking feature is available.
With a 3-inch touch screen and a sliding QWERTY keyboard, the LG Xpression 2 is closer to a smartphone without being a smartphone. The QWERTY keyboard makes it less difficult to write a message than on maximum fundamental telephones, although the buttons are small. In addition, the screen automatically switches between a horizontal and vertical view, maximizing the amount of area on the screen to read texts. However, the LG Xpression 2 also offers many distractions. The Gameloft Little Big City game is integrated into the phone, which you can’t remove. The touchscreen also makes it less difficult and more intuitive to browse and interact with the web. You can drag your finger up and down with your finger, for example, even if you can’t zoom in or out by pinching your hands (you have to use the magnifying glass). Some other people have complained, and we agree, that the touchscreen is not responding and, in our tests, the telephone seemed to have difficulty staying connected to the Internet. The popular telephone now also has limited availability.
Additional report through Thorin Klosowski.
Christine Elgersma, editor-in-chief, Common Sense Media, telephone interview, September 13, 2018
Anya Kamenetz, from The Art of Screen Time: How Your Family Can Balance Digital Media and Real Life, telephone interview, September 17, 2018
Megan Moreno, MD, pediatrician and lead author of the American Academy of Pediatrics Policy Statement on Children and Media Use, Telephone Interview, October 2, 2018
Chris Chuang, founder and CEO of Relay, face-to-face interview, March 13, 2019
Kaiwei Tang, co-founder and CEO of Light, interview, March 20, 2019
Eric Wong, Director of Digital Marketing and E-Commerce, Doki, Interview, May 9, 2019
Ramon Llamas, Director of Mobile Device Research, IDC, Interview, May 24, 2019
Jessica Grose, The Rise of Location Trackers for children up to 3 years old, The New York Times, March 5, 2020
Kaz Weida, The Best Smart Watches for Kids, Safewise, April 8, 2020
Sascha Segan, Best Phones for Kids, PCMag, April 29, 2020
Ellen Lee
by Ellen Lee
We tested seven parental features and found that Apple Screen Time is the most productive for iOS users and Google Family Link is the most productive for Android users.
by Christine Cyr Clisset
Whether you send your child back to school, do distance learning plans, or prepare for a hybrid of both, here’s the device you need.
by Winnie Yang
We talk to game specialists, robotics experts and music teachers to locate the most productive activities for children’s boredom and entertainment.
by Lauren Dragan and Brent Butterworth
We tested 30 helmets of limited volume and spoke to experts from WHO and CDC; while many were not working as expected, the Pure BT2200 is the option.
Let’s be friends!
You can send us a note.
© 2020 Wirecutter, Inc., a New York Times company